May 13, 2009
Above is a photo that one of my friends on Twitter sent me. He basically downloaded one of my cartoons off my blog, printed it out, and stuck it outside his cube at work, for other people to see, hopefully to comment on, and hopefully, to start a conversation.
This, I believe, is where my cartoons work the best- "Cube Grenades"- small objects that you "throw" in there in order to cause some damage- to start a conversation, to spread an idea etc.
[The Blue Monster]
The Microsoft Blue Monster is probably my best-known Cube Grenade, which is why I made it into a limited edition print eventually.
Seth Godin first put his Purple Cow book into a purple milk carton for the same reason- he guessed [quite rightly, as it turned out] that people would see the carton on somebody's desk, inquire about it, and a conversation about the marketing ideas contained in the book would be started.
[The Purple Cow print]
And the Purple Cow print was designed the same way. OK, it might be a bit big to display in a cube- you need a lot of wall space for this one- but the idea is the same- Conversations that happen around the object are more interesting than the actual object itself.
"Cube Grenades". Exactly. Cartoons designed to affect change as "Social Objects". Exactly.
[Check out some of my limited edition prints over at gapingvoidgallery.com.]
Since I posted this "Cube Grenades" idea yesterday, I've been giving it A LOT of thought. Here are some notes:
[More "Cube Grenades" in action. Click on image to enlarge etc.]
1. Like I said, my cartoons work best when they're used as "Cube Grenades" i.e. small objects that you "throw" in there in order to cause some damage- to start a conversation, to spread an idea etc. But other social objects can be used as well- purple milk cartons, homemade cookies, funky mousepads, rubber toys, newspaper clippings etc. It's the people that matter, not the object they socialize around. I don't claim to have a monopoly.
2. Repeat After Me: Cube Grenades are Social Objects. Cube Grenades are Social Objects. Cube Grenades are Social Objects...
3. All big change in companies come from the people in the trenches, who do the actual day-to-day work. To change their behavior, you have to change the way they interact. People interact around social objects. Change the social objects, and you change the company.
4. My friend, Mark Earls once told me a story about a friend of his. The friend played a key role in the massively successful corporate turnaround recently undertaken by McDonald's.
His friend told him, "We knew we were screwed, NOT when the nutrition and green issues started hitting the newspapers, but by the simple fact that our staff on the floor just weren't cleaning the tables and the bathrooms like they used to. We knew THEN that our people had lost faith in our company."
What social objects were people using, both during the company's decline and during its turnaround? What cube grenades were being thrown about, both before and after? I bet you they weren't the same.
5. Yes, I am fully aware that your customers are paying for the quality of the products and services your business provides, not for the quality of the cube grenades flying around your corporate headquarters. But they are all related. Everything of value that your business creates is the product of a already-existing social dynamic. Businesses are people, not machines. And people socialize around objects.
6. An Open Letter to Ad Agencies: Guys, you are NOT selling messages anymore. You are selling social objects. The work that you create will affect the cube grenades and social objects, that your clients and their customers use to interact with each other.
[More Cube Grenades. "I use them as covers for my binders strewn about my desk, to start conversations", says the person who e-mailed me the photo. Click on image to enlarge etc.]
7. You see a guy walking out of an Apple store, looking all excited about his new Apple computer he's carrying under his arm? Why is he so excited? Sure, he just got himself a nice-looking piece of kit, but what REALLY excites him is all of the COOL, DISRUPTIVE STUFF he's going to MAKE with his new machine. Videos, music mixes, whatever. For his FRIENDS and his PEERS. Again, it's the SOCIAL that makes it interesting. Apple makes cube grenades, just like the ad agencies. Just like you do.
8. People download my cartoons and stuck them on their walls by the THOUSANDS. A much smaller number spend money to buy the more expensive versions i.e. my prints. But the idea is the same i.e. a way for people to interact. As I'm fond of saying: The conversations AROUND the object are FAR more interesting than the object itself. And what is true for me is true of your product, as well. "People Matter. Objects don't." Exactly.
9. So when do I start charging? You can download my stuff for free, so why should you buy a print? Who says you should? I'm guessing that if one of my cartoons is meaningful enough to you, you'll get tired of seeing it printed on the office laserprinter paper in low-resolution, getting all worn and torn, with the Scotch tape getting all yellow and crinkly. If you like the drawing enough, eventually you'll want to upgrade. The same way, back in college, that I would upgrade to vinyl or CDs, once the cheap and nasty cassette tape of my favorite band started getting all fuzzy and worn out. The same way I gladly paid $20 to hear the band play live, rather than hear the same songs on the cassette. "Meaning Scales". The more cube grenades I throw out there, the more meaningful interaction I create for other people, the more people will want to pay for it eventually. If I locked it all down as a cash-only transaction, it would all die a horrible death overnight.
[Privately-commissioned "Cube Grenades" i.e. limited edition, fine art prints that I did for my Brazilian client, agenciaclick. Click on image to enlarge etc.]
10. Probably the job I'm most proud of recently, is when I was hired by a Brazilian ad agency, agenciaclick to create a privately commissioned edition of cube grenades i.e. fine art prints. See photo above.
They didn't want these prints for themselves; they wanted to give these out to their clients, as conversation starters.
"All brands are open brands? Huh? What does that mean? Do you agree with it? Why? What does "open" actually mean? What does "brand" actually mean...?" You get the picture. The same idea that made The Blue Monster so successful. Again, it wasn't about the message, the object. It was all about the social.
11. My long-term goal is to make more privately-commissioned "Cube Grenades" for more clients like agenciaclick. It was a wonderful working experience for me, and I want to spend more time in that business. If you find this idea interesting, please feel free to e-mail me at email@example.com. Thanks.
To keep everything on the same page, I copied & pasted the entire "Ad Agency Pitch" from May 30th below. Thanks.
[Signing the agenciaclick cube grenade a couple of weeks ago...]
Over the last couple of weeks I've been talking with various advertising and PR folk about the Cube Grenade idea. Here are some notes:
1. In terms of the advertising and PR industries, the Cube Grenade is basically conceived as a relatively cheap and effective Social Object to articulate the Purpose-Idea of a brand or company.
2. If the agency has an idea they REALLY want to sell to their client, they might have better luck if they first articulate the idea via a Cube Grenade designed by me, rather than the traditional "agency pitch" model. The agency's idea is somehow articulated as a commissioned print, the print is given out as a gift, to people within the relevant constituency. The print hangs on a wall, other people see it, and if the idea is any good then people will start talking about it. That conversation will lead to other conversations. If the idea is any good, other ideas [and opportunities] will be spawned from it.
3. The Cube Grenade is not a glorified advertising poster. I'm not primarily interested in why people should buy the client's product per se. I'm far more interested in the human dynamic, the collective human drive that makes the client's people want to get up in the morning and go to work. That is where THE REAL VALUE is created.
4. Because the Cube Grenade is given as a gift- an act of love, as it were- AND NOT A DELIVERABLE WANTING TO BE SOLD, it will break through the cultural barriers of the client company a lot more cheaply and quickly than your standard "Big Advertising Idea". The game here is not about "Selling An Ad", the point is to make the client more alive, more human, more aware of their own human potential. Again, this is where is where THE REAL VALUE for the client-agency relationship is created.
5. Whether the Cube Grenade "works" or not in the end, both agency and client will find out if the thought behind it works A LOT sooner and inexpensively than executing your average ad campaign. Like all communication, the idea needs to RISK FAILURE if it's ever to be any good. "Fail cheap, fail often", as the great venture capitalist, Esther Dyson likes to say.
6. As I've said before to the ad agencies: "Guys, you are NOT selling messages anymore. You are selling Social Objects. The work that you create will affect the Cube Grenades and Social Objects, that your clients and their customers use to interact with each other." This is why I'm talking to advertising folk. At the end of the day, we're both in the same business.
7. To get more background reading, please visit my Cube Grenade archive here. You might also want to check out "The Hughtrain" to get a better understanding of where my ideas are coming from.
8. As always, if this idea is of any interest to you, please feel free to contact me at firstname.lastname@example.org. Or if you know someone in the advertising industry, please send them along to this page [Here's the link]. Thanks!
Posted by hugh macleod at May 13, 2009 7:49 PM
I do this with your cartoons as well. Ha, cube grenades. Love that. I do have interesting conversations, no doubt. Thanks Hugh.
Is it legal to download and print your content just like that?
Thanks for using the photo of my cube and your awesome cartoon.
I can honestly say that it sparks more comments and discussions (some of the "if HR knew about this" variety) than anything else I've ever put on my wall.
When the job or life has me down, I think about trying to live up to that standard of "being totally fucking amazing".
Thanks again for blogging about the photo; I love the cube grenade terminology.
Thanks for talking to me at SXSW this year.
Thanks for calling me a friend.
yep, had "hamster wheel" on the cube wall just the other day. lots of funny looks. some explanation of what's a "hugh"
You got microsoft just right
Don't have a cube at my office, (I work mobile), but have the next best thing - your cartoons as my desktop and screensaver. They definitely start conversations.
I can (and do) change them to reflect what is happening in the market or within the company. We are currently in a pretty big merger, so your "Permanent State of Reinvention" is there at the moment.
It starts conversations with whoever sees it...
I used to keep a couple print outs of that cartoon that I would slip into people's mailboxes. I also had a tiny print out of it that I kept right under my receiver on my desk phone, so every time I picked up the phone I would see it.
i founded a startup with 2 other ex-Microsoft guys, several years ago. We had a printout of the Blue Monster cartoon on the door of our basement office for the longest time with Microsoft scratched out and our startup's name in its place. Change the World or Go Home. In fact that was the only decoration we had in the office!
3. All big change in companies come from the people in the trenches.
An empowering fantasy, but a fantasy nonetheless. The people in the trenches can profoundly influence the executives, but the change can and will only come when those in charge make it so.
The famed and still relevant W. Edwards Deming used to say "The problem is at the top; management is the problem." ..."Dr. Deming emphasized that the top-level management had to change to produce significant differences, in a long-term, continuous manner."
Dondo, "Make it so"? Make what so? Management actually makes nothing.
Generals don't kill the enemy. People under their command kill the enemy.
Not that Generals don't provide an invaluable service, of course...
Hugh's cartoons are definitely conversation starters. Besides having one on my business cards, there are several in the office.
The best conversation generated was from "Mediocrity sucks'" as my screen saver. I booted up the laptop for the webex and it changed the whole tone of the meeting. As one VP said, "No one wants to be mediocre."
I've used your cartoons in conversations, in presentations - to illuminate, upset, motivate, change people I cared for. And sometimes people whom I wished I could shake out of whatever moment they were stuck in. I don't have a cubicle any more. And that's the whole point. In the same ways that others have written about escaping from cubicle nation, people like you, and Godin, get some of us to turn the ship of their lives in a different direction. It's violent, sometimes uncomfortable process. You play with a grenade at your own risk. But it's what we need, sometimes, to get us out of our comfort zone. You always do. Love this.
I work in technical services at a big university here in Canada. At convocation all of the of graduates must walk by my computer screen, which has its desktop background, "People Matter. Objects Don't."
I had at least a dozen people comment on it, and many more stare at it while they were waiting to get their degree.
It is something I have to remind myself of daily, because it is too easy to see people as inconvenient when in reality, I am able to feed myself because of these people.
(I also have your, "I work extremely hard doing what I love, mainly to ensure that I don't have to work extremely hard doing what I hate" above my desk for those nights I have to pull the ridiculous hours schooling and work require)
Thank you for inspiring someone who spent 10 years doing what he hated before he risked doing what he loved.
I put the
one as my desktop sometimes. Although the top row should really be "Clueless Sociopaths"
Go Hugh! I love the summation of your creativity rift, engraved on my iPod- "Work hard. Be nice".
Although I'm not in a cube, I *do* have bluetrain #4 on my wall - a definite conversation starter. I love what I do, but I do wish at this moment, that I worked for Sony Pictures Entertainment chief executive officer Michael Lynton!
For me buying one of your prints wasn't only about having one of my favourite messages on the wall in art form. It was also my way of saying thank you! for the thoughts you're sharing here with us.
I must have read your "bio" 10 times. And I'm sure I'll read it again. I've never read a more personal and honest "CV". Well, to be precise: I've never read a cv with drawings in it. It was a WOW! moment. That was my cube grenade.
Yes. For a few weeks now, I have had the IGNORE EVERYBODY print as the desktop image on one of my monitors...the one that is least often cluttered with documents and programs. I love it.
I'm glad I was using it as you intended.
Hugh; First, thanks for the continuous inspiration.
Second, a short (true) story: A few years ago I worked for a high end, hand built bicycle company where my job was to guide the design team (notice I don't say "manage"). With far, far less artistry than you I created and posted a Cube Bomb. It said simply, "Strong, Light, Cheap. Pick any two." To keep the story short let me just say that it was so disruptive that I was threatened by my GM and, literally, forced to take it down. No amount of explaining could convince him to let it stay up.
Some years have passed and I now work for another company. My former company no longer hand builds bicycles in North America but instead produces them in China. Go figure.
Can you give us a link to the original "Quality not job one" cartoon?
Cube Grenades are Social Objects. Cube Grenades are Social Objects. Cube Grenades are Social Objects...
Good idea, i've just started a "change all desktop" operation ;)
Generals don't kill the enemy. People under their command kill the enemy.
Not that Generals don't provide an invaluable service, of course...
Hugh, have you got a cartoon illustrating the above, or similar?
It especially resonates with my current situation where middle and upper management are pushing to meet targets and deadlines, meeting quality control standards, intra office politicking, while no one is focusing on actually making the funny stories happen...
(and that I could do something about it, if I really wanted to.)
I'm so happy to have a name for these now: Cube Grenade. Yes.
Ever since finding them, I have been emailing your cartoons off to cause trouble.
Now I almost wish I had a cube.
Find it interesting to read this blog post about 'cube grenades', as I found it quite interesting/amusing to put up one of your cartoons (the lifestyle remained) on my twin monitor displays that are *extremely* visible in my corner spot of a low-panelled cubicle.
Plenty of footfall past that corner gave rise to various comments, raised eyebrows or just inquisitive expressions. Interesting material.
Reckon that a simple screensaver with alternating cartoon images might be a useful approach too. Obviously that only works when not at my desk, or not using my PC, but still a wortwhile idea, I think.
After finding your cartoons the first thing that really made me want to share them, and the thing that made it more possible, is the creative commons license you have on your work.
Seeing your cartoons everyday is the mini kick up the ass I need to get working sometimes.
@John Rutter: in Windows XP and above, use the My Pictures Slideshow screensaver, which should be included in a standard installation. Create a folder of Hugh's cartoons, somewhere within My Pictures perhaps, and set the Slideshow Screensaver to use that folder as its picture source (right-click on the desktop and select screensaver, then find "My Pictures Slideshow").
And this is of course very possible in most other GUI-based modern operating system. Those more familiar with OS-X and/or Ubuntu/Gnome/KDE/X-ScreenSaver can perhaps enlighten us.
I planted a Cube Grenade of "If you talked to people the way advertising ..." behind my desk (on an ad agency).
It stood there for 3 years.
Nobody bother to asked me what it meant or who did it.
So last Friday, my last day (i resigned), i posted on the monitor and left, and on my goodbye email i launched my last grenade and emailed everyone at the Office the Cluetrain Manifesto. Maybe that would help.
I look forward to keep throwing more cube Grenades on my new job. May I borrow some of the cartoons of your new book? (still have to order it though, as i missed the chance to get a free one).
Keep those Cube Grenades coming, Hugh.
I don't have any walls by my desk, but have created a screen saver featuring some of my fave cartoons.
it's like the small gurilla stuff, really interesting post, spinvox have been getting cube grenades out there for ages with their little spinvox men - http://blog.spinvox.com/ definitely an interesting talking point, nice bunch of people too
I have my "cube grenades" on the wall in my hallway at home, see picture: http://www.belowbelief.com/archives/2009/05/crazy-deranged-fools.php where they regularly get conversations started when guests come round.
And I regularly "throw grenades" into an emailed newsletter at work to cause trouble or just to make people take things less seriously. They do cause a raised eyebrow here and there sometimes.
Thanks for letting us use them in this way Hugh and yes - I might very well upgrade to the "higher quality" version soon.