Nov 18, 2026

Give Your Team a Waterslide

Give Your Team a Waterslide

In the tabletop role-playing game Dungeons & Dragons, there’s a player called the Dungeon Master (DM). Think of them as the architect of the adventure. They’re responsible for creating the world, facilitating the game, and guiding the story as it unfolds.

DMs typically take one of two approaches, colloquially called “Railroad” and “Sandbox.”

The “Railroad DM” ignores player agency and forces everyone down one path, my-way-or-the-highway style. You didn’t want to fight the vampire, so you walked in the opposite direction of their castle? Too bad. You’ve just been kidnapped by their underlings and dragged to the castle anyway. Let the battle ensue.

The Railroad DM preps everything, putting in hours of work to make sure everything is perfect, often leaving a table of frustrated, ignored players. 

Whereas the Sandbox DM lets you step into a world that is your oyster. You won’t be pressured to do anything you don’t want to do…or anything at all, for that matter. As you sit at a table with your character sheet in front of you, directionless and panicked, you realize the story is fully in your hands. In the made-up land where everything is possible, it might actually be nice if someone could nudge you in a direction. 

Too much control is no fun. Too little control is no fun for entirely different reasons.

To break this impasse, Dungeon Master Brennan Lee Mulligan described his DM style as neither a Railroad nor a Sandbox, but something akin to a “Waterslide” (1:29:56). 

In this scenario, the DM sets certain parameters. The water is always flowing in one direction. There’s an agreed-upon destination and a structure that keeps everyone moving toward it. But the journey isn’t a straight line. There are twists and turns, surprises, and opportunities for players to shape the experience.

Freedom without direction can feel like abandonment. Direction without freedom can feel like coercion. And that’s the dilemma leaders face every day.

The sweet spot is a culture that gives people a destination worth pursuing, the autonomy to find their own way there, and enough room for a little adventure along the way.

Let’s Talk

* Required